Protecting the accuracy and integrity of the scholarly record.
IRJAR is committed to correcting the academic record when errors, ethical concerns, authorship issues, copyright problems, or research integrity concerns are identified before or after publication.
Accuracy
IRJAR corrects significant errors when they affect clarity, metadata, attribution, interpretation, or the scholarly record.
Transparency
Serious post-publication changes should be documented clearly rather than hidden through silent removal.
Fair review
Authors, readers, reviewers, editors, and complainants are treated with fairness, evidence, and professionalism.
1. Purpose of this policy
The purpose of this Corrections and Retractions Policy is to explain how the Interdisciplinary Research Journal & Archives, also known as IRJAR, responds when published or submitted work requires correction, clarification, withdrawal, expression of concern, or retraction.
This policy applies to journal articles, books, book chapters, reviews, essays, special issues, archives, conference proceedings, metadata records, DOI-related records, author profiles, and other scholarly materials published or managed by IRJAR.
IRJAR’s goal is not to punish honest error. The goal is to protect readers, authors, reviewers, institutions, and the integrity of the scholarly record.
2. Core principles
IRJAR handles corrections and retractions according to principles of fairness, transparency, editorial independence, evidence-based review, and respect for the permanence of academic publishing.
Transparency
Significant changes to published work should be explained through visible notices, correction statements, updated metadata, or retraction notices where appropriate.
Proportionality
Minor typographical issues should not be treated like research misconduct. The response should match the seriousness of the problem.
Due process
Authors should normally have an opportunity to respond to concerns unless urgent legal, ethical, privacy, or safety risks require immediate action.
Preservation
Published scholarly records should be preserved whenever possible. Corrections and retractions are generally preferred over silent deletion.
3. Types of editorial actions
IRJAR may use different editorial actions depending on the nature, timing, and seriousness of the concern.
| Action | When it may apply | Typical outcome |
|---|---|---|
| Minor update | Small typographical, formatting, link, layout, or metadata issues that do not affect meaning. | The page or file may be updated without a formal correction notice. |
| Correction | Errors that affect clarity, citation, metadata, author information, interpretation, or a specific claim, but do not invalidate the work. | A correction notice or updated version may be published. |
| Expression of concern | Serious concerns exist but the investigation is incomplete or evidence remains unresolved. | A temporary notice may alert readers while review continues. |
| Withdrawal | A manuscript or pre-publication file should be removed before final publication. | The manuscript may be removed from workflow or marked withdrawn. |
| Retraction | Serious problems undermine the reliability, legality, ethics, originality, or integrity of the publication. | A retraction notice is published and linked to the original record where possible. |
| Removal | Exceptional cases involving legal orders, serious privacy risk, safety threats, defamatory content, or unlawful material. | Content may be removed or restricted, with a public notice where appropriate. |
4. Corrections
A correction may be issued when a published work contains an error that should be fixed for accuracy, clarity, attribution, discoverability, or scholarly integrity, but the error does not invalidate the publication as a whole.
Corrections may be appropriate for:
- Incorrect author names, affiliations, biographies, ORCID iDs, or contact information.
- Errors in title, abstract, keywords, DOI metadata, page numbers, issue details, or citation information.
- Incorrect references, missing citations, incomplete bibliographic information, or broken DOI links.
- Errors in tables, figures, captions, charts, images, or appendices.
- Factual errors that require clarification but do not undermine the entire argument.
- Missing acknowledgements, funding information, ethics approval details, or conflict-of-interest disclosures.
When a correction is significant, IRJAR may publish a correction notice explaining what was changed, why it was changed, and when the correction was made.
5. Retractions
A retraction is a serious editorial action used when a publication should no longer be relied upon as part of the scholarly record. Retraction does not necessarily mean every author acted dishonestly; it means the published work contains a serious problem that affects its reliability, legality, originality, or ethical standing.
Retractions may be appropriate when there is evidence of:
- Plagiarism, self-plagiarism, or duplicate publication.
- Fabricated, falsified, manipulated, or unreliable data.
- Major methodological or analytical errors that invalidate the findings.
- Unethical research involving participants, communities, interviews, private data, or sensitive information.
- Copyright infringement or unauthorized use of protected materials.
- False authorship, ghost authorship, forged approval, or serious authorship disputes.
- Undisclosed conflicts of interest that seriously affect interpretation.
- Defamatory, unlawful, dangerous, or seriously misleading content.
A retraction notice should clearly identify the publication, explain the reason for retraction, and remain linked to the original publication record when possible.
6. Withdrawals before publication
Withdrawal may apply before final publication when an author requests removal from consideration, when a submission was made in error, when serious concerns are identified during review, or when IRJAR determines that the manuscript should not proceed.
A manuscript may be withdrawn when:
- The author formally requests withdrawal before publication.
- The manuscript is under review elsewhere without disclosure.
- Co-author approval is missing or disputed.
- Ethics approval, permission, or required documentation is unavailable.
- Serious plagiarism, copyright, or legal concerns arise before publication.
- The author does not respond to essential editorial requests within a reasonable period.
Once a work is formally published, withdrawal is generally no longer the preferred term. Corrections, retractions, or removal notices may be more appropriate.
7. Expressions of concern
IRJAR may publish an expression of concern when serious questions have been raised about a publication but the evidence is not yet complete, the investigation is ongoing, or author/institutional responses are pending.
An expression of concern may be used when:
- There are credible allegations of research misconduct but the investigation is unresolved.
- There is uncertainty about data reliability, authorship, ethics approval, or permission.
- Legal, institutional, or editorial review is still in progress.
- Readers should be alerted while IRJAR gathers evidence.
An expression of concern may later be removed, replaced by a correction, replaced by a retraction notice, or updated with the outcome of the review.
8. Review process for correction or retraction concerns
IRJAR reviews correction and retraction concerns carefully. The process may vary depending on urgency, evidence, publication type, legal risk, privacy risk, and the seriousness of the issue.
Concern received
IRJAR receives a concern from an author, reader, reviewer, editor, institution, copyright holder, or affected party.
Initial assessment
The editorial team reviews whether the concern appears credible, urgent, relevant, and supported by sufficient information.
Evidence gathering
IRJAR may request documents, permissions, data, author responses, institutional input, reviewer feedback, or copyright evidence.
Author response
Where appropriate, authors are invited to respond to the concern and provide clarification or supporting evidence.
Editorial decision
IRJAR decides whether to take no action, issue a correction, publish an expression of concern, withdraw, retract, or restrict content.
Public notice and record update
When necessary, IRJAR updates the publication record, DOI metadata, article page, PDF, archive entry, or public notice.
10. Publication record, DOI metadata, and archiving
IRJAR values the permanence and transparency of the scholarly record. When a correction, retraction, withdrawal, or expression of concern is issued, IRJAR may update the article page, PDF, metadata, archive entry, DOI-related record, table of contents, and relevant publication notices.
When possible, the original publication record should remain discoverable with a clear notice explaining the editorial action. This helps readers understand what changed and why.
Public notices may include:
- The title of the affected publication.
- Author name or publication metadata.
- The type of editorial action.
- The reason for the action.
- The date of the correction, concern, withdrawal, or retraction.
- A link to the corrected version, retraction notice, or updated record.
11. How to submit a correction or retraction request
Authors, readers, reviewers, editors, institutions, or copyright holders may contact IRJAR if they believe a publication requires correction, clarification, withdrawal, expression of concern, or retraction.
Your request should include:
- Your full name and contact information.
- Your relationship to the publication, such as author, reader, reviewer, institution, or copyright holder.
- The title of the publication.
- The author name, DOI, URL, publication date, or issue information if available.
- A clear description of the concern.
- Specific location of the problem, such as page number, paragraph, table, figure, reference, or metadata field.
- Supporting evidence or documentation.
- The action requested, such as correction, metadata update, retraction review, or permission review.
Email IRJAR at support@irjar.org with the subject line: “Correction or Retraction Request.”
12. Frequently asked questions
Can a published article be silently deleted?
Does a correction mean the author committed misconduct?
Does a retraction mean every author acted dishonestly?
Can authors request a correction after publication?
Can readers report suspected plagiarism or copyright infringement?
Will DOI metadata be updated after a correction or retraction?
13. Contact for corrections and retractions
Questions about corrections, retractions, withdrawals, expressions of concern, copyright concerns, authorship disputes, metadata errors, or publication integrity should be directed to IRJAR.
IRJAR CORP.
Registered in Manitoba, Canada
Business Number: [IRJAR BUSINESS NUMBER]
Website: irjar.org
Email: support@irjar.org
Corrections protect trust in academic publishing.
IRJAR is committed to maintaining a credible scholarly record through responsible correction, transparent review, ethical publishing, and respect for authors, readers, institutions, and the public.